19
2500 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226, USA
Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226
+1 414-778-1590

So, I've been to Five Guys twice now. And like my first time there. I left after my second visit thinking the same thing... this place is OVERPRICED!

Slow as all hell. Waited 20 mins after my burger was put together and wrapped. Before I was given my meal. Food was cold.

No Milkshake or any dessert options. Just Burger, Dogs and Fries.

Why so damn expensive?! I guess maybe they try and make up for the steep price by throwing extra fries in the order. But, to me, NOTHING will justify a freakin' normal burger and fries for $10 or more! That's ridiculous!

There is no 'EAT-IN' option. By default all orders are packed (with excess paper and wrapping) for take-out. Irresponsible on the environment.

Everything is fresh and cooked to order (cook only after its ordered).

But seriously? Almost $8 for a freaking double cheeseburger?! With really no difference than most places... no really interesting or crazy condiment choices... they're not huge... they're normal size burgers that are just a little better quality than some. That's it!

You get to customize your Burger with Mayo, Mustard, Ketchup, Grilled Onions, Grilled Mushrooms etc. for no extra charge.

Love this place. The staff are friendly and help out when ever asked. It can be loud but that causes of the mall crowd.

Can't say I'll be back anytime soon... especially since this is also the second time the cashier has seemed to be in a mood... if you don't like your job at least put on a friendly smile or quit...

At least a place like AJ Bombers throws in some interesting things for their burgers to justify their prices...

Some variety with Fries with Cajun style as well, although they put too much seasoning on it. You feel you have to wipe you fingers every 30 seconds while eating them. Grimy stuff.

Oh, and another thing, the menu prices Google shows are NOT correct! I wish they were as the prices shown on here are actually reasonable!

A reasonable selection of Sodas and drinks plus bottled water.

Yesterday I went and the fries are good, but WAY TO MANY. The screaming is VERY ANNOYING and they have all the food in bags and it's like you can't eat in. I wish they said that the BLT included Mayo because I wasted 8 bucks on a BLT that I didn't eat I ate only the fries.

Maybe I'm a cheap ass... but I CAN understand paying a little more for quality! But $8 for a burger?! $4 for a regular fries is justified by the amount you get.

The Burger was OK (time taken to prepare was 5 minutes which was also OK). But would I pay $13.23 for the whole thing? Probably not.

The whole Peanuts that you can eat while you wait for your order is a nice feature. I availed of this. Never turn down Peanuts.

Yes, the quality of the food is THERE. Natural fries cooked in peanut oil(you can smell it). 100% beef burgers cooked well and never greasy. Great.

Show Map

Five Guys — Meal Takeaway in Wauwatosa

We are glad to greet you!

Five Guys

Meal Takeaway at 2500 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226, USA. Here you will find detailed information about Five Guys: address, phone, fax, opening hours, customer reviews, photos, directions and more.

Opening hours

  • Monday
    10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Tuesday
    10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Wednesday
    10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Thursday
    10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Friday
    10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Saturday
    10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Sunday
    11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Rating

4
/
5
Based on 19 reviews

Contacts

Categories:
State:
Wisconsin
Address:
2500 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226, USA.
City:
Wauwatosa
Postcode:
53226

About Five Guys

Five Guys is a US Meal Takeaway based in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. Five Guys is located at 2500 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226, USA.


Please contact with Five Guys using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Five Guys opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.

Are you the owner?
You can make a change to the page:
Edit this page

ALL reviews about Five Guys

  • Aaron
    Added 2016.09.08
    So, I've been to Five Guys twice now. And like my first time there. I left after my second visit thinking the same thing... this place is OVERPRICED!
  • Kyle
    Added 2016.08.22
    Slow as all hell. Waited 20 mins after my burger was put together and wrapped. Before I was given my meal. Food was cold.
  • Owen
    Added 2016.05.14
    No Milkshake or any dessert options. Just Burger, Dogs and Fries.
  • Xavier
    Added 2016.04.19
    Why so damn expensive?! I guess maybe they try and make up for the steep price by throwing extra fries in the order. But, to me, NOTHING will justify a freakin' normal burger and fries for $10 or more! That's ridiculous!
  • Colin
    Added 2016.02.26
    There is no 'EAT-IN' option. By default all orders are packed (with excess paper and wrapping) for take-out. Irresponsible on the environment.
  • Jake
    Added 2016.02.02
    Everything is fresh and cooked to order (cook only after its ordered).
  • Trinity
    Added 2015.05.26
    But seriously? Almost $8 for a freaking double cheeseburger?! With really no difference than most places... no really interesting or crazy condiment choices... they're not huge... they're normal size burgers that are just a little better quality than some. That's it!
  • Steven
    Added 2015.03.11
    You get to customize your Burger with Mayo, Mustard, Ketchup, Grilled Onions, Grilled Mushrooms etc. for no extra charge.
  • Jason
    Added 2014.09.13
    Love this place. The staff are friendly and help out when ever asked. It can be loud but that causes of the mall crowd.
  • Paige
    Added 2014.05.16
    Can't say I'll be back anytime soon... especially since this is also the second time the cashier has seemed to be in a mood... if you don't like your job at least put on a friendly smile or quit...
  • Arianna
    Added 2014.05.03
    At least a place like AJ Bombers throws in some interesting things for their burgers to justify their prices...
  • Zoe
    Added 2014.01.06
    Some variety with Fries with Cajun style as well, although they put too much seasoning on it. You feel you have to wipe you fingers every 30 seconds while eating them. Grimy stuff.
  • Steven
    Added 2013.11.20
    Oh, and another thing, the menu prices Google shows are NOT correct! I wish they were as the prices shown on here are actually reasonable!
  • Ariana
    Added 2013.11.08
    A reasonable selection of Sodas and drinks plus bottled water.
  • Adam
    Added 2013.10.19
    Yesterday I went and the fries are good, but WAY TO MANY. The screaming is VERY ANNOYING and they have all the food in bags and it's like you can't eat in. I wish they said that the BLT included Mayo because I wasted 8 bucks on a BLT that I didn't eat I ate only the fries.
  • Avery
    Added 2013.10.14
    Maybe I'm a cheap ass... but I CAN understand paying a little more for quality! But $8 for a burger?! $4 for a regular fries is justified by the amount you get.
  • Molly
    Added 2013.10.01
    The Burger was OK (time taken to prepare was 5 minutes which was also OK). But would I pay $13.23 for the whole thing? Probably not.
  • Xavier
    Added 2013.08.06
    The whole Peanuts that you can eat while you wait for your order is a nice feature. I availed of this. Never turn down Peanuts.
  • Lauren
    Added 2013.04.25
    Yes, the quality of the food is THERE. Natural fries cooked in peanut oil(you can smell it). 100% beef burgers cooked well and never greasy. Great.
Leave your own review about Five Guys:
Add a review